Investigation of Public Libraries Managed by Outsourcing: A Study Focusing on Library Usage, Opening Days, and Directors’ Librarian Qualifications and Workloads
Public libraries in Japan were managed by local governments for a long time. However, in 2003, organizations including private enterprises, NPOs and foundations took over their management with the introduction of an outsourcing system, namely the ‘designated administrator system’. The question of whether this outsourcing system is appropriate for public libraries is a subject of current debate, wherein many argue that it is inappropriate. To provide basic data for this discussion, we conducted a cross-sectional and time series analysis on almost all public libraries in Japan focusing on library usage, number of open days, and director qualifications and workload. The results show that the opening days and percentage of certified directors of public libraries managed by the outsourcing system (‘outsourcing libraries’) was more than those managed by local governments (‘direct management libraries’), whereas the number of Inter-Library Loan (ILL)-borrowings and the number of ILL-lending were more in direct management libraries than in outsourcing libraries. It was also shown that the library usage and open days, as well as the number of certified directors increased after the introduction of the outsourcing system.
Japan Library Association, Statistics on Libraries in Japan 2005-2015 edition, 2006-2016. (text in Japanese).
Japan Library Association, “About designated administrator system for public libraries,” http://www.jla.or.jp/library/tabid/311/Default.aspx. (text in Japanese).
Japan Association for Promotion of Social Education, “Japan association for promotion of social education’s View for official documents on designated administrator system on January 25th, 2005 by ministry of education, culture, sports, science and technology,” 2005; http://japse.main.jp/wp-content/uploads/kenkai20050528.pdf. (text in Japanese).
The Society of study on library problems, “Appeals against adoption of designated administrator system in Public Libraries,” July 2006; http://www.jca.apc.org/tomonken/apeal20060711-1.html. (text in Japanese).
T. Maruyama, “Further seriousness of seven-year-old designated administrator: The Yamanakako public library for the people’s creativity and the society for digitization of local materials (NPO) and the future of library,” Social Education, vol. 65, no. 10, 2010, pp.66-69. (text in Japanese).
H. Yorozuya, “How is regular staffs in the regularization: with the designated administrator,” Everyone’s library, no. 441, 2014, pp.45-49. (text in Japanese).
H. Maeda, “A Study on the Actual State of Introduction of Designation Administrator System to Public Libraries,” Summaries of Technical Papers of Annual Meeting Architectural Institute of Japan. E-1, Architectural Planning and Design I, Building Types and Community Facilities, Planning and Design Method Building Construction System Human Factor Studies Planning and Design Theory 2007, 2007, pp.109-110. (text in Japanese).
Committee on library policies of Japan Library Association, “Results of the questionnaire on introduction of designated management system in libraries,” Libraries Today, vol. 45, no. 1, 2007, pp. 41-51. (text in Japanese).
N. Koyama and H. Nagata, “Report on Public Library Management,” 2008; http://www.slis.tsukuba.ac.jp/grad/assets/files/project/h19/report.pdf. (text in Japanese).
G. Yamaguchi, “In order to accomplish the purpose of establish, effectively; Public library can develop when local governments have responsibility,” Japanese Publications News and Reviews, no. 2461, 2017, pp.4-9.(text in Japanese).
Y. Kambayashi, “Non-regular workers and outsourcing method in public library management,” Libraries Today, vol. 47, no. 3, 2009, pp. 145-157. (text in Japanese).
N. Shiomi, “Some thoughts on the present situation of the designated management system,” Library Journal, vol. 105, no. 7, 2011, pp.428-431. (text in Japanese).
R. Mouri and I. Ohba, “Desirable capabilities for public library directors in Japan,” Library World, vol. 66, no. 5, 2015, pp.326-342. (text in Japanese).
S. Nobuta, “A comparative study of public libraries’ management,” The Journal of Otemae Women’s University, vol. 22, 1988, pp.210-236. (text in Japanese).
S. Nobuta, “Comparative study on public library’s activities with the director’s librarianship,” The Journal of Otemae Women’s University, vol. 29, 1995, pp.127-143. (text in Japanese).
T. Watanabe, “Reconsidering the value of reference service in public libraries in Japan,” Library and Information Science, no. 66, 2011, pp.153-165. (text in Japanese).
S. Yasuda, “The tracks of reference service for 12 years: from the experience in Toyota city library,” Library World, vol. 59, no. 3, 2007, pp.202-209. (text in Japanese).
Y. Miyakawa，M. Honma, and N. Kanou, “An increase in the total opening hours of university libraries as a consequence of societal needs: relationship with setting up of evening classes,” The journal of Information Science and Technology Association, vol. 65, no. 2, 2015, pp.79-82. (text in Japanese).
K. Tsuji, “Investigation on the Elements of Learning Commons that Increase Library Use,” Proceedings of the Asia-Pacific Conference on Library & Information Education & Practice 2015 (A-LIEP 2015), pp.38-51.
Japan Library Association, “Report about Public Libraries Managed by Designated Administrator System,” http://www.jla.or.jp/library/tabid/311/Default.aspx. (text in Japanese).
ILL the acronym of Interlibrary loan and a service whereby a patron of one library can borrow materials that are owned by another library.
Reference Transactions are information consultations in which library staff recommend, interpret, evaluate, and/or use information resources to help others to meet particular information needs (defined by RUSA: A division of the American library association, http://www.ala.org/rusa/guidelines/definitionsreference).
In Japan, city is defined as a municipality that has a population over 50,000 and especially ‘ordinance-designated city’ is defined as a city that has a population greater than 500,000. ‘Tokyo special wards’ are 23 municipalities that have highest population density in Japan. Towns and villages are the other municipalities, which are smaller than the others: cities and Tokyo special wards.
Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications, “Survey on the Introduction of the Designated Administrator System,” 2012; http://www.soumu.go.jp/iken/siteikanrisya dounyujyoukyou kohyou h240401.html. (text in Japanese).
H. Minai, “How reference service of libraries should be,” The journal of Okinawa library association, no. 9, p.82-103, 2005. (text in Japanese).
S. Niioka, “A Study on the Legal Limitations of Introduction of Designated Administrator System to Public Libraries,” Hokkaido University Collection of Scholarly and Academic Papers, Graduate School of Education, vol. 130, p. 133-149, 2018. (text in Japanese).